Is static_cast misused?

I have mixed feelings about static_cast, as it is the safest C++ cast available, but allows both safe and unsafe conversions at the same time, so you have to know the context to say if it is actually safe or might lead to UB (e.g. when casting to a sub-class).

So why isn't there a safer explicit cast? Here is an example, where it could be useful. In COM, they have to return the interface pointer as void** ppv, so "have to" cast explicitely

*ppv = (IInterface*) this;

which was then suggested to be replaced by a safer C++ cast

*ppv = static_cast<IInterface*>(this);

But does it make sense to make even a static_cast here? this is of a class which derives from IInterface, so one could simply write

IInterface* p = this; // implicit conversion 开发者_如何学Pythonto base, safe for sure
*ppv = p;

or use a helper like

template<class T, class U>
T implicit_cast(U p) { return p; }

*ppv = implicit_cast<IInterface*>(this);

So, is it true that static_cast is sometimes misused and can (should?) be replaced by this implicit_cast in some cases, or am I missing something?

EDIT: I know that a cast is required in COM, but it does not have to be static_cast, an implicit cast would be enough.

---

In this particular case I believe that it's always known that the casting will be upwards and that therefore static_cast should be perfectly safe.

It does appear that using your implicit_cast would probably be safer, and allows you to explicitly pick which base class you want to implicitly cast to (which is apparently required for COM).

I did a quick test with g++ and implicit_cast does indeed return different addresses for different base classes as expected.

Do note however that in regards to your very first sentence I would argue that dynamic_cast is in fact safer than static_cast since it will return null or throw if the cast can't be completed. In contrast, static_cast will return a valid-looking pointer and let you keep going until your program blows up at some time in the future, unconnected to the original bad cast.

Test program:

#include <iostream>

class B1
{
public:
    virtual ~B1() {}
};

class B2
{
public:
    virtual ~B2() {}
};

class Foo : public B1, public B2
{
};

template<class T, class U>
T implicit_cast(U p) { return p; }

int main()
{
    Foo* f = new Foo;
    void **ppv = new void*;

    *ppv = implicit_cast<B1*>(f);
    std::cout << *ppv << std::endl;;
    *ppv = implicit_cast<B2*>(f);
    std::cout << *ppv << std::endl;;

    return 0;
}