drupal (CMS) or codeigniter (MVC) for creating a new web application? [closed]_问答_开发者

Closed. This question is opinion-based. It is not currently accepting answers.

Want to improve this question? Update the question so it can be answered with facts and citations by editing this post.

Closed 9 years ago.

Improve this question

I am going to create a new web application that is very customized.

It will contain images, that are fully searchable - in a very, very customized way.

When you click on the pictures you can add comments and so on.

It requires users to be registered, but the registration/login process will be highly customized too.

At the moment I am using CodeIgniter for this. But I've read a lot of posts about CMS like Drupal and it sounds like I could let it handle basic stuff, maybe design and other front end work.

I have no experience with CMS, in fact, I just started to use a MVC framework like CI and was impressed of how much easier it gets to start developing.

So, i wonder, if i'm going to create this kind of application, could I use drupal and then add the usual stuff, as I was going to do with CodeIgniter, like controllers, views, models, config files, my own libraries and so on?

How does it work on a system like Drupal? How do you code PHP with it as with any MVC framework. It sounds like it has a lot of modules, I just wonder, if I can use it as a MVC framework but have the benefit of having all these basic stuff and design ready to use? It sounds like the best "library" to provide for a web application from scratch.

Is it difficult to create a customized app with it? I guess it has modules like images and users, but then how could I customize these so that every image has tags on it and country information, or have every user subscribing to changes to an image, that email will be sent to users and so on?

I guess it is easy to install a module. The question is, how do I customize it. maybe I don't need all that table columns. Maybe I want to add/remove business logic.

What are the pros and cons with using Drupal for this? Is it even the right way to go?

Can you make a Stackoverflow with Drupal? Facebook? Twitter? Youtube? assuming that you know php of course.

Share your thoughts because I am to开发者_C百科tally new on creating a web application!

Thanks

I think this is a great article for everyone who has "CodeIgniter vs. Drupal" dilemma.
If you are like me:

like writing CODE
want your web site/web application to do and looks EXACTLY how you want
in love with KISS philosophy (keep it small and simple)
upgrade when YOU want

Than you will take CodeIgniter path.
(I'm telling you that after more than two years building Drupal websites)

Using Drupal is a fine idea -- it can take care of the mundane details like user registration, authentication, etc.

Then you extend drupal by writing a module or three.

The interaction between drupal's core and your module is going to be a pretty well-defined thing.

The internals of module can be structured however you want. You could even use an MVC framework!

I did a project once that did just that. It was a custom drupal module that internally used Zend Framework's MVC stack.

Worked like a charm.

There's definitely a learning curve for drupal in general and module development particuarly, but it's not insurmountable.

I have seen fully fledged web applications written in Drupal. Drupal is really handy for offloading the boring bits of the web application - user authentication and authorisation, comments, captcha, theming etc.

It really lets you get that head start into writing code for your application. With the stable release of Drupal 7 just around the corner, why not give it a shot?