Regex redefinition error

I am using python, and run into some redefinition error, I know they are redefinition but logically its not possible to reach that since its an or. Is there a way to get around this? I appreciate for any help in advance

/python-2.5/lib/python2.5/re.py", line 233, in _compile raise error, v # invalid expression sre_constants.error: redefinition of group name 'id' as group 9; was group 6

import re

DOB_RE =  "(^|;)DOB +(?P<dob>\d{2}-\d{2}-\d{4})"
ID_RE =   "(^|;)ID +(?P<id>[A-Z0-9]{12})"
INFO_RE = "- (?P<info>.*)"

PERSON_RE = "((" + DOB_RE + ".*" + ID_RE +  ")|(" + \
                   ID_RE  + ".*" + DOB_RE + ")|(" + \
                   DOB_RE + "|" + ID_RE + ")).*(" + INFO_RE + ")*"

PARSER = re.compile(PERSON_RE)

samplestr1 = garbage;DOB 10-10-2010;more garbage\开发者_StackOverflow中文版nID PARI12345678;more garbage
samplestr2 = garbage;ID PARI12345678;more garbage\nDOB 10-10-2010;more garbage
samplestr3 = garbage;DOB 10-10-2010
samplestr4 = garbage;ID PARI12345678;more garbage- I am cool

---

Regular expression syntax simply does not allow multiple occurrences of identically-named groups -- groups that aren't "reached" are defined to be "empty" (None) on a match.

So you have to change those names e.g. to dob0, dob1, dob2 and id0, id1, id2 (then you can easily "collapse" these sets of keys to make the dict you actually want after you have a groups dictionary from a match).

E.g., make the DOB_RE a function instead of a constant, say:

def DOB_RE(i): return "(^|;)DOB +(?P<dob%s>\d{2}-\d{2}-\d{4})" % i

and similarly for the others, and change the three occurrences of DOB_RE in the statement where you compute PERSON_RE to DOB_RE(0), DOB_RE(1) etc (and similarly for the others).

---

I was originally going to post a pyparsing example using the Each class (which picks out expressions that can be in any order), but then I saw that there was intermixed garbage, so searching through your string using searchString seemed a better fit. This intrigued me because searchString returns a sequence of ParseResults, one for each match (including any corresponding named results). So I thought, "What if I combine the returned ParseResults using sum - what a hack!", er, "How novel!" So here's a never-before-seen pyparsing hack:

from pyparsing import *
# define the separate expressions to be matched, with results names
dob_ref = "DOB" + Regex(r"\d{2}-\d{2}-\d{4}")("dob")
id_ref = "ID" + Word(alphanums,exact=12)("id")
info_ref = "-" + restOfLine("info")

# create an overall expression
person_data = dob_ref | id_ref | info_ref

for test in (samplestr1,samplestr2,samplestr3,samplestr4,):
    # retrieve a list of separate matches
    separate_results = person_data.searchString(test)

    # combine the results using sum
    # (NO ONE HAS EVER DONE THIS BEFORE!)
    person = sum(separate_results, ParseResults([]))

    # now we have a uber-ParseResults object!
    print person.id
    print person.dump()
    print

Giving this output:

PARI12345678
['DOB', '10-10-2010', 'ID', 'PARI12345678']
- dob: 10-10-2010
- id: PARI12345678

PARI12345678
['ID', 'PARI12345678', 'DOB', '10-10-2010']
- dob: 10-10-2010
- id: PARI12345678


['DOB', '10-10-2010']
- dob: 10-10-2010

PARI12345678
['ID', 'PARI12345678', '-', ' I am cool']
- id: PARI12345678
- info:  I am cool

But I do also speak regex. Here is a similar approach using re's.

import re

# define each individual re, with group names
dobRE = r"DOB +(?P<dob>\d{2}-\d{2}-\d{4})"
idRE = r"ID +(?P<id>[A-Z0-9]{12})"
infoRE = r"- (?P<info>.*)"

# one re to rule them all
person_dataRE = re.compile('|'.join([dobRE, idRE, infoRE]))

# using findall with person_dataRE will return a 3-tuple, so let's create 
# a tuple-merger
merge = lambda a,b : tuple(aa or bb for aa,bb in zip(a,b))

# let's create a Person class to collect the different data bits 
# (or if you are running Py2.6, use a namedtuple
class Person:
    def __init__(self,*args):
        self.dob, self.id, self.info = args
    def __str__(self):
        return "- id: %s\n- dob: %s\n- info: %s" % (self.id, self.dob, self.info)

for test in (samplestr1,samplestr2,samplestr3,samplestr4,):
    # could have used reduce here, but let's err on the side of explicity
    persontuple = ('','','')
    for data in person_dataRE.findall(test):
        persontuple = merge(persontuple,data)

    # make a person
    person = Person(*persontuple)

    # print out the collected results
    print person.id
    print person
    print

With this output:

PARI12345678
- id: PARI12345678
- dob: 10-10-2010
- info: 

PARI12345678
- id: PARI12345678
- dob: 10-10-2010
- info: 


- id: 
- dob: 10-10-2010
- info: 

PARI12345678
- id: PARI12345678
- dob: 
- info: I am cool

---

Perhaps in this case it is better to loop through a list of regular expressions.

>>> strs=[
... "garbage;DOB 10-10-2010;more garbage\nID PARI12345678;more garbage",
... "garbage;ID PARI12345678;more garbage\nDOB 10-10-2010;more garbage",
... "garbage;DOB 10-10-2010",
... "garbage;ID PARI12345678;more garbage- I am cool"]
>>> import re
>>> 
>>> DOB_RE =  "(^|;|\n)DOB +(?P<dob>\d{2}-\d{2}-\d{4})"
>>> ID_RE =   "(^|;|\n)ID +(?P<id>[A-Z0-9]{12})"
>>> INFO_RE = "(- (?P<info>.*))?"
>>> 
>>> REGEX = map(re.compile,[DOB_RE + ".*" + ID_RE + "[^-]*" + INFO_RE,
...                         ID_RE + ".*" + DOB_RE + "[^-]*" + INFO_RE,
...                         DOB_RE + "[^-]*" + INFO_RE,
...                         ID_RE + "[^-]*" + INFO_RE])
>>> 
>>> def get_person(s):
...     for regex in REGEX:
...         res = re.search(regex,s)
...         if res:
...             return res.groupdict()
... 
>>> for s in strs:
...     print get_person(s)
... 
{'dob': '10-10-2010', 'info': None, 'id': 'PARI12345678'}
{'dob': '10-10-2010', 'info': None, 'id': 'PARI12345678'}
{'dob': '10-10-2010', 'info': None}
{'info': 'I am cool', 'id': 'PARI12345678'}