C# FindAll VS Where Speed

Anyone know any speed differences between Where and FindAll on List. I know Where is part of IEnumerab开发者_如何学Gole and FindAll is part of List, I'm just curious what's faster.

---

The FindAll method of the List<T> class actually constructs a new list object, and adds results to it. The Where extension method for IEnumerable<T> will simply iterate over an existing list and yield an enumeration of the matching results without creating or adding anything (other than the enumerator itself.)

Given a small set, the two would likely perform comparably. However, given a larger set, Where should outperform FindAll, as the new List created to contain the results will have to dynamically grow to contain additional results. Memory usage of FindAll will also start to grow exponentially as the number of matching results increases, where as Where should have constant minimal memory usage (in and of itself...excluding whatever you do with the results.)

---

FindAll is obviously slower than Where, because it needs to create a new list.

Anyway, I think you really should consider Jon Hanna comment - you'll probably need to do some operations on your results and list would be more useful than IEnumerable in many cases.

I wrote small test, just paste it in Console App project. It measures time/ticks of: function execution, operations on results collection(to get perf. of 'real' usage, and to be sure that compiler won't optimize unused data etc. - I'm new to C# and don't know how it works yet,sorry).

Notice: every measured function except WhereIENumerable() creates new List of elements. I might be doing something wrong, but clearly iterating IEnumerable takes much more time than iterating list.

using System;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Linq;
using System.Text;
using System.Diagnostics;

namespace Tests
{

    public class Dummy
    {
        public int Val;
        public Dummy(int val)
        {
            Val = val;
        }
    }
    public class WhereOrFindAll
    {
        const int ElCount = 20000000;
        const int FilterVal =1000;
        const int MaxVal = 2000;
        const bool CheckSum = true; // Checks sum of elements in list of resutls
        static List<Dummy> list = new List<Dummy>();
        public delegate void FuncToTest();

        public static long TestTicks(FuncToTest function, string msg)
        {
            Stopwatch watch = new Stopwatch();
            watch.Start();
            function();
            watch.Stop();
            Console.Write("\r\n"+msg + "\t ticks: " + (watch.ElapsedTicks));
            return watch.ElapsedTicks;
        }
        static void Check(List<Dummy> list)
        {
            if (!CheckSum) return;
            Stopwatch watch = new Stopwatch();
            watch.Start();

            long res=0;
            int count = list.Count;
            for (int i = 0; i < count; i++)     res += list[i].Val;
            for (int i = 0; i < count; i++)     res -= (long)(list[i].Val * 0.3);

            watch.Stop();
            Console.Write("\r\n\nCheck sum: " + res.ToString() + "\t iteration ticks: " + watch.ElapsedTicks);
        }
        static void Check(IEnumerable<Dummy> ieNumerable)
        {
            if (!CheckSum) return;
            Stopwatch watch = new Stopwatch();
            watch.Start();

            IEnumerator<Dummy> ieNumerator = ieNumerable.GetEnumerator();
            long res = 0;
            while (ieNumerator.MoveNext())  res += ieNumerator.Current.Val;
            ieNumerator=ieNumerable.GetEnumerator();
            while (ieNumerator.MoveNext())  res -= (long)(ieNumerator.Current.Val * 0.3);

            watch.Stop();
            Console.Write("\r\n\nCheck sum: " + res.ToString() + "\t iteration ticks :" + watch.ElapsedTicks);
        }
        static void Generate()
        {
            if (list.Count > 0)
                return;
            var rand = new Random();
            for (int i = 0; i < ElCount; i++)
                list.Add(new Dummy(rand.Next(MaxVal)));

        }
        static void For()
        {
            List<Dummy> resList = new List<Dummy>();
            int count = list.Count;
            for (int i = 0; i < count; i++)
            {
                if (list[i].Val < FilterVal)
                    resList.Add(list[i]);
            }      
            Check(resList);
        }
        static void Foreach()
        {
            List<Dummy> resList = new List<Dummy>();
            int count = list.Count;
            foreach (Dummy dummy in list)
            {
                if (dummy.Val < FilterVal)
                    resList.Add(dummy);
            }
            Check(resList);
        }
        static void WhereToList()
        {
            List<Dummy> resList = list.Where(x => x.Val < FilterVal).ToList<Dummy>();
            Check(resList);
        }
        static void WhereIEnumerable()
        {
            Stopwatch watch = new Stopwatch();
            IEnumerable<Dummy> iEnumerable = list.Where(x => x.Val < FilterVal);
            Check(iEnumerable);
        }
        static void FindAll()
        {
            List<Dummy> resList = list.FindAll(x => x.Val < FilterVal);
            Check(resList);
        }
        public static void Run()
        {
            Generate();
            long[] ticks = { 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 };
            for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++)
            {
                ticks[0] += TestTicks(For, "For \t\t");
                ticks[1] += TestTicks(Foreach, "Foreach \t");
                ticks[2] += TestTicks(WhereToList, "Where to list \t");
                ticks[3] += TestTicks(WhereIEnumerable, "Where Ienum \t");
                ticks[4] += TestTicks(FindAll, "FindAll \t");
                Console.Write("\r\n---------------");
            }
            for (int i = 0; i < 5; i++)
                Console.Write("\r\n"+ticks[i].ToString());
        }
    
    }

    class Program
    {
        static void Main(string[] args)
        {
            WhereOrFindAll.Run();
            Console.Read();
        }
    }
}

Results(ticks) - CheckSum enabled(some operations on results), mode: release without debugging(CTRL+F5):

 - 16,222,276 (for ->list)
 - 17,151,121 (foreach -> list)
 -  4,741,494 (where ->list)
 - 27,122,285 (where ->ienum)
 - 18,821,571 (findall ->list)

CheckSum disabled (not using returned list at all):

 - 10,885,004 (for ->list)
 - 11,221,888 (foreach ->list)
 - 18,688,433 (where ->list)
 -      1,075 (where ->ienum)
 - 13,720,243 (findall ->list)

Your results can be slightly different, to get real results you need more iterations.

---

UPDATE(from comment): Looking through that code I agree, .Where should have, at worst, equal performance but almost always better.

Original answer:
.FindAll() should be faster, it takes advantage of already knowing the List's size and looping through the internal array with a simple for loop. .Where() has to fire up an enumerator (a sealed framework class called WhereIterator in this case) and do the same job in a less specific way.

Keep in mind though, that .Where() is enumerable, not actively creating a List in memory and filling it. It's more like a stream, so the memory use on something very large can have a significant difference. Also, you could start using the results in a parallel fashion much faster using there .Where() approach in 4.0.

---

Where is much, much faster than FindAll. No matter how big the list is, Where takes exactly the same amount of time.

Of course Where just creates a query. It doesn't actually do anything, unlike FindAll which does create a list.

---

The answer from jrista makes senses. However, the new list adds the same objects, thus just growing with reference to existing objects, which should not be that slow. As long as 3.5 / Linq extension are possible, Where stays better anyway. FindAll makes much more sense when limited with 2.0