Which is better, return "ModelAndView" or "String" on spring3 controller

The way of return ModelAndView

@RequestMapping(value = "/list", method = RequestMethod.GET)
public ModelAndView list(
    @UserAuth UserAuth user, 
    ModelAndView mav) {

    if (!u开发者_如何转开发ser.isAuthenticated()) {
        mav.setViewName("redirect:http://www.test.com/login.jsp");
        return mav;
    }

    mav.setViewName("list");
    mav.addObject("articles", listService.getLists());

    return mav;
}

The way of return String

@RequestMapping(value = "/list", method = RequestMethod.GET)
public String list(
    @UserAuth UserAuth user, 
    Model model) {

    if (!user.isAuthenticated()) {
        return "redirect:http://www.test.com/login.jsp";
    }

    model.addAttribute("articles", listService.getLists());

    return "list";
}

These work same. which is better way? and what is difference?

---

There is no better way. Both are perfectly valid. Which one you choose to use depends which one suits your application better - Spring allows you to do it either way.

Historically, the two approaches come from different versions of Spring. The ModelAndView approach was the primary way of returning both model and view information from a controller in pre-Spring 2.0. Now you can combine the Model parameter and the String return value, but the old approach is still valid.

---

I would like to add me 2 cents also. Second approach is more towards convention oriented i.e developer does explicitly mention what is his view but its implicit that return string is view name. So less coding,readable and standard. Much better than older way with ModelAndView