I'm trying to decompose several tables into BCNF. I believe the first one is decomposed correctly, but I'm unsure whether or not the others can be decomposed. Any help is appreciated
**make(id, name, est, founder, city, state)**
id->name;
name->est, city, state, founder;
city->state
New Relations: [Key(id),name], [Key(name),est,city,state,founder], [Key(city),state]
**model(id, makeId, name, year, category)**
id->makeId, name;
name->year, category (not superkey, but can't really decompose)
**features(i开发者_Go百科d, modelId, abs, tpms, sidebags, drl)**
id->modelID, abs, tpms, sidebags, drl
**user(id, name, pass, first, last, phone, isAdmin)**
id->name, pass, isAdmin; name->first, last, phone
**selling(id, price, modelId, mileage, userId)**
id->price, modelId, mileage, userID
BCNF is easy: just make sure all dependencies between attribute sets in a single relation are dependencies on a superkey of the relation. Your first one is close, but the second relation needs to omit "state". Often, people stop at 3NF since not all relations with FDs have dependency-preserving BCNF decompositions. Do you need help decomposing the other relations? I will help, if you need it.
Edit: Help on other relations.
Selling and Features are fine. Models and Users need to be split on Name in order to be in BCNF; you indicate this isn't something you can do for Models. Why? Name implies the stuff on the right of the arrow, right?
精彩评论