开发者

PHP-Java interop - Gearman or PJB?

开发者 https://www.devze.com 2023-02-19 06:35 出处:网络
Which i开发者_开发知识库s the overall best option for calling Java from PHP? Gearman PHP/Java Bridge

Which i开发者_开发知识库s the overall best option for calling Java from PHP?

  • Gearman
  • PHP/Java Bridge

or something else entirely? By "best" I mean easy to use, reliable, transparent (for debugging purposes) - the whole enchilada.

To put it the other way, does either solution have any major shortcomings?

Edit: the reason for this is a PHP site which needs to use a 3rd party SOAP service. The type hierarchy defined in the WSDL appears to be too complex for any pure PHP client.


The PHP/Java bridge is functional, but we found that it tended to leave around zombie JVM processes as Apache children that have to be kill -9'd to get rid of. We ended up running a cron job daily to take care of the problem. We only used it for one specific class (an interface class to someone's horrid SOAP endpoint), and it was a tad bit finicky when it came to type juggling, but it did work for us. (The zombie process problem may have been due to the prehistoric PHP version we were using at the time, so it may have been fixed by now.)

I don't have any experience with Gearman and Java, but plenty of it with PHP. It's been a pleasure to work with, for the most part. The most annoying issue is that processing async updates from the caller requires some pretty verbose code to handle all of the possible states. For fire-and-forget and fire-and-get-back-immediate-results RPC, though, it's really hard to beat.


Gearman is probably not really the solution you are after (unless you really want a job queue rather than some form of RPC). It can operate in a blocking/synchronous fashion but it brings alot of overhead (code/application/etc wise) to the party for what i'm guessing is a simple task?

Without knowing what you are trying to do i'm going to throw some suggestion out there. XML-RPC (can be slightly less evil than SOAP!) or maybe something like Facebook's Thrift[1], Apache Avro[2], or Google Protocol Buffers[3]?

[1] http://incubator.apache.org/thrift/

[2] http://avro.apache.org/

[3] http://code.google.com/apis/protocolbuffers/

0

精彩评论

暂无评论...
验证码 换一张
取 消